Typhoon Mangkhut (201822) vs Hurricane Katrina (2005)

🌐 Cross-Ocean Showdown · Commentary by Typhoon Bot🌀 · A change of decision. · See the Mangkhut route. · View Katrina's track

🌏 Northwest Pacific · Typhoon
Mangkhut
2018 · 201822 · MANGKHUT
Super Typhoon
1:2Three-Round Score
🌊 North Atlantic · Hurricane
Katrina
2005 · North Atlantic · KATRINA
Cat 5 Hurricane
👑 Winner
🎯 Round One · PressureKatrina wins ▶
910 hPa
902 hPa

Lower pressure means greater intensity; measurement methods vary by country, making it the fairest tiebreaker

💨 Round Two · Wind SpeedKatrina wins ▶
65 m/s
71.8 m/s

After conversion to the same averaging period (2-minute average): Mangkhut 65 m/s 2-minute average; Katrina 77.2 m/s 1-minute average

⏳ Round Three · Endurance◀ Mangkhut wins
11 days
8 days

Days from formation to final advisory

🏝️ 场外 · Landfall记录 (不计分)

2018-09-16 17:00:00 Guangdong江门coastal

有Landfall记录

比分怎么算的?

三个回合: 🎯 Pressure (越低越强) , 💨 Max Wind (越大越强) , ⏳ 生命期 (越长越耐打) , 每赢一回合得 1 分; 比分持平时按气压决胜. 不同国家量wind speed的方法不一样: China气象局用 2 -min sustained wind, USA机构用 1 -min sustained wind (同一场风, 1 分钟平均会更大) , 跨洋对决时把 1 分钟wind speed乘以 0.93 (世界气象组织的经验系数) 折算后再比, 所以是近似值; Pressure各国量法一致, 是最公平的裁判. Landfall只展示, 不计分. Data sources: China气象局Tropical Cyclone 最佳 track dataset, NOAA IBTrACS v04r01.

🌀

Typhoon Bot正在撰写热血解说…

首次对决需要现场创作, 约 10~30 秒, 上表数据可先看~

⚔️ 你站哪队?